Pavlina Tesch the best offer usually comes from asking your members. One of the questions you can ask them is How can we thank you for your participation in this program? Swag & Giftcards, Exclusive content & education, Exclusive events & opportunites, or a Thank you note.
That will send you in the right direction, and whoever responds you can ask them more pointed questions. For general B2B SaaS business audiences I know the latest cup is owala, but people also like nice branded clothes like North Face.
For developers, IT, etc. They might be interested in the product features or time with your IT teams, intros to others in your space, etc.